Recasting 2021: "Mass"

In 2020, I completed a year-long recasting project with my entry on Frances McDormand's Academy Award-winning performance in Nomadland. I followed it up a couple years later with my similarly themed supporting project. I had always intended to continue on with entries for each year, but I wanted to give things some time to breathe. So here I am, exactly five years later, to provide my updated list. I'll be posting an entry every Monday until I've completed recasting lead roles from 2021-2025, and supporting roles from 2023-2025. 

My selection for 2021 has been one that I've had in mind pretty much since it was released. Mass is a chamber piece by American Fran Kranz in his directorial debut. The film follows a meeting between two couples who get together to discuss, question, and hopefully find a way to heal in the aftermath of their sons'deaths. The tricky part is, one of the sons was murdered in a school shooting by the other couple's sons. Right off the bat, it's a difficult concept and scenario, right up Meryl's alley. 

The role I've specifically chosen to recast is Ann Dowd's role of Linda, the mother of the shooter, who subsequently took his own life after the shootings. As always, my intention with imagining recasting Meryl in the role is not to impugn Dowd's work. She is absolutely brilliant in the movie and I have no way of knowing if I'd prefer Meryl to her or anyone else (or in any other film). It's just fun to imagine, the same way I enjoy seeing different performers cast in the same play or opera. As an aside, it's always been a bit perplexing that people tend to get a little antagonized at the suggestion of someone wanting to see other actors in previously cast parts. We do it (and enjoy or even crave it) in other mediums. Why should film or TV be any different? 

Anyway, I rewatched the movie this week for the first time since it came out. I remember enjoying it and being very impressed by both the screenplay and acting performances. I have to say, I was even more impressed the second time around. Talk about tackling difficult topics! Dowd is partnered by Reed Birney, who plays the perpetrators father. The parents of said victim are portrayed by Jason Isaacs and Martha Plimpton. Six years have passed since the tragic shootings, but emotions are still raw, as the couples meet in a church basement to chat. 

I wish I could find a more lengthy clip of one of Dowd's monologues, but alas, no luck. You get a sense of what the back and forth is like. The conversation touches on gun violence of course, the politics surrounding access to firearms, parenting, and mental health. Compelling arguments and questions are raised by all performers (who by the way are all exceptional in their respective roles), but for me, the crux of what all it came down to, from a personal level, is that the parents of the victim just wanted to have a place to put their pain. The way I experienced it in watching the movie, was that they wanted so badly to hear from the shooter's parents that there was a clear, identifiable reason of how or where they had gone wrong as parents. Then they could have an answer, a living culprit, an object for their anger and emptiness. The trouble is, there probably wasn't any one thing the parents of the shooter did that was much different from what any other parent who loved their son would've done. And, possibly, they did more than most parents would do to tackle any red flags they encountered about their son's behavior. That's what's so maddening and painful about it, I think, for the parents of the victim. Maybe it wasn't preventable, as far as the behavior of the shooter's parents was concerned. 

Ultimately, we get to see what looks like some catharsis and forgiveness, when Plimpton's character shares after all their discussion that she though (paraphrasing) that she'd lose her son if she forgave the shooter's parents. Wow! But that she realized this wasn't the case, and the anger and resentment, and her desire for the other parents to be punished began to lift. 

The film received overwhelmingly positive reviews, with a 95% on Rotten Tomatoes and a score of 81 on Metacritic, indicating "universal acclaim." I realize that all of Dowd's recognition came in the form of nominations in the Supporting Actress category, but I think it's totally reasonable for the four main characters in this movie to be considered lead. Realistically, if Streep had been in the film, it might've actually been easier for Plimpton to get more noms in supporting, as they would've put Meryl, the more seasoned actor and bigger name, in lead.