Recasting 2023: "Nyad"

Way back in 2015, I posted about whether or not Meryl might star in a script from that year's Hollywood Black List. The overwhelming candidate was Robert Specland's script about marathon swimmer Diana Nyad, fittingly titled, Nyad. I'll say up front that at the time, Meryl would've been a perfect age to portray Nyad, who, in the story is in her early 60s. Fast forward to 2023, and Annette Bening eventually stars in the  movie, with a new script by Julie Cox, based on Nyad's 2015 memoir, Find a Way. 

I had been fortunate enough to read Specland's script, and I found it wonderful. To be honest, I don't remember a ton of differences between his and Cox's, but I think the latter puts more focus on the relationship between Nyad and her longtime friend and former coach, Bonnie Stoll. I even suggested at the time that Jodie Foster would be a good fit to direct or even star as Stoll, the latter of which she did (the actual directors were Elizabeth Chai Vasarhelyi and Jimmy Chin, in their narrative directorial debuts). I can remember having understood that Meryl swam for exercise, and that although it seemed a bit of a stretch for her to want to do something so physically demanding, the challenge itself would've been an exciting prospect. 

Nyad grew up as a competitive and decorated swimmer. In her twenties, she attempted to become the first person to swim from Cuba to Key West and failed. Not until she was in her early 60s did she set out to try again, and on the fourth try, she made it. Quick note: her swim has not been ratified by the World Open Water Swimming Association due to various discrepancies with documenting the swim. But my guess is that she did it. And she was the first to do it not inside a shark cage, which, when used, can apparently increase your speed. 

The movie itself tracks Nyad's preparation and attempts at the swim. She corrals her friend and formerly brief love interest, Bonnie Stoll to help coach and train her. Tons of things go wrong along the way. But the story is kind of like Titanic, where even though you know what's going to happen, if the movie is good enough, you wonder if you might just be wrong. Bening succeeds at characterizing the passion and drive Nyad had to have to even consider such a daunting feat. We learn that much of the drive behind her efforts is related to abuse she suffered at the hands of her former coach, and one has to wonder if her completing the swim is sort of like Clarice Starling in The Silence of the Lambs, where Hannibal Lecter identifies that Clarice wants to save a young woman from being murdered in an attempt to silence the screams of a lamb she was unable to save as a child, the same way Diana can overcome her traumas by putting her mind to and accomplishing the seemingly insurmountable achievement. 

I have to admit that Bening's performance, while very good, doesn't really remind me of Nyad herself. I've seen a handful of interviews with Nyad, and I just don't see much resemblance. Maybe she wasn't going for a super close characterization, more of capturing of her spirit or a more general idea of her. Not that I desire actors to completely mimic real people they're playing, but I enjoy (particularly if I'm familiar with the person), getting fooled a little that it's really that person on the screen. Meryl, of course, is exceptional at that, and I suspect that she would've taken pains to match Nyad's distinct style of speech. Nyad's father was Greek-Egyptian as well, and I've heard her do a great impression of him with his accent. She also speaks Spanish in the film, which I believe Nyad speaks fluently. 

A quick note on age: re-watching the film, Bening and Foster definitely just feel younger. They are younger than Mery, of course, but the tone of the film would probably have been a bit different if Meryl had been in the role. She's definitely played people over ten years younger than her on paper (Streep would've been 72 when filming (Nyad was 64 when she completed her Cuba-Florida swim). Totally doable. But the biggest difference I think there would've needed to is recasting Bonnie as well. I've often thought that Sigourney Weaver would've been great in the role, and she would likely seem much more of a realistic contemporary to Streep's Nyad, which I think is important for the story. Foster could've stayed attached as director, though! 

The film did pretty well with critics, standing at 85% on Rotten Tomatoes and a respectable 63 score on Metacritic. It was a Netflix film, so although it debuted at Telluride and had a short run in theaters, it pretty much didn't make any box office money. Bening and Foster both earned Academy Award nominations for their performances, in lead and supporting, respectively.