Recasting 2022: "Mrs. Harris Goes to Paris"

The selection for this year was also rather easy for me. I saw the movie sometime in 2022 and not only quickly considered it for my recasting project, but ended up liking it enough I revisited it more than once following. Mrs. Harris Goes to Paris is a delightful comedy adaptation of Paul Gallico's 1958 novel. I'm pretty sure I saw the 1992 TV version starring Angela Lansbury when I was a kid (titled, like the novel, without the "H" in "Harris", to account for how the characters actually pronounced it).  

The plot follows Ada Harris, a war widow in 1950's London. She's works as a cleaning lady who dreams of purchasing a couture Christian Dior gown, after having seen one in her employer's closet. Through a series of happy accidents, she comes up with enough money to make the trip to Paris, thinking she'll just step in to the shop and buy the dress she wants. Enter Dior director, Claudine Colbert (portrayed by Isabelle Huppert), who's not a big fan of Ada's humble background and the sort of tarnish she seems to think it has on the house name. The problem is, the other employees are endeared by Ada, and they do what they can to make sure she gets her dress fitted. When she returns to London, she lends her dress to a dumb actress who manages to burn it to shreds on a heater. And in a serendipitous turn of events, the dress that Ada had originally wanted (they're couture so there's only one!), became available, and due to the impression she left on the employees at Dior, they send it to her with warmest regards. Hurray!

It's a bit of a sugary movie, but it works. And if realistically considering the order of the few previous films I've included in my lead recasting project (The Wife, Catherine the Great, Nomadland, Mass), they're not exactly romps, and therefore a bit of lighter fair at this point would be very much due. There's also more to the role than the sort of good vibes we get from things working out for Ada. Meryl would be able to unpack the sort of baggage that Ada carries with her regarding her MIA husband. It's more like denial, and those close to her seem to recognize that, and perhaps even Ada does, but she doesn't want to quite believe that he's never coming back. 

There's also the juxtaposition of class. Meryl certainly explored this in The Iron Lady. And although much of the Mrs. Harris Goes to Paris takes place in France, the vibe is the same, where simply by the fact that she's not an aristocrat or politician or the wife of a prominent businessman, that she doesn't belong. The scenes with Isabelle Huppert would've been nice to see. There are some fun back-and-forths between those two characters. On the surface, Huppert's character seems kind of one-note. But even for a relatively small role, we get some background on her sort of hard exterior, as it's revealed that she cares for an elderly and infirm father. 

I can't help but think about the movie The Hundred-Foot Journey when watching this movie. There's the French snootiness and strong patrician character who looks down on a new and possibly less polished person in her arena. And the tones are similar. There's conflict, but you always kind of get the sense that things are going to work out for the people you're rooting for, which again, seems like a good fit following a string of very serious selections in this lead recasting series. 

The film was praised by critics, with a 94% on Rotten Tomatoes and 70 on Metacritic. Manville was particularly lauded, deservedly, garnering a Golden Globe nomination for Best Actress in a Musical or Comedy. And for a rather modest budget (which would've been slightly less modest I imagine, had Meryl been in the pic), it was a box office success, earning $31.4 million against a budget of around $10-12 million.